Mayhem greets Lily when she comes home for her father's funeral. Even worse, she realizes she's in love with Cain and Zach Young, two boys she once had a crush on. Now, they are men—and willing to share.

The will states she'll inherit the family ranch on two conditions -- she must marry Cain, and the ranch must show a profit in a year. That's not an easy feat since the foreman has been rustling most of the cattle. Her love for Cain and Zach overwhelms her as much as the financial problems.

When the ex-foreman kidnaps Lily, he tells her he is her half-brother, and that Cain was aware of the relationship. Devastated, Lily turns away from Cain. Even worse, Zach sticks by his brother, and Lily can't have one without the other. Can she learn to forgive Cain so the three of them can find everlasting happiness?